- Fink 🧠
- Posts
- 🔔 Why The Fed Won't Go Big Tonight
🔔 Why The Fed Won't Go Big Tonight
Let's kick off with a shout out to Macrodesiac partner Syscoin. 👇
Build the future on Syscoin: The best of Bitcoin and Ethereum in one place
Why the Fed won't hike by 50 tonight 👇
Wait. That's not it.
"Because it's the Fed's job to prop up the stock market, duuuh"
OK. Proper (boring) answer.
Because it's the least bad option.
The Fed's always wrong. They're the fall guys. Sometimes it's more justified than others, but they'll rarely get praised.
I like to frame their decisions by asking which is the 'least bad' option available at each meeting.
Without the Ukraine conflict, choosing between a 0.25% and 0.5% hike would have been far closer.
This thread from WSJ Fed Watcher Nick Timiraos is a great summary of reasons why the Fed should go with a 50 bps hike:
For the Fed, the inflation headaches are becoming one damn thing after another.
Officials were banking on a drop in goods prices to bring inflation down.
Then came war, and an oil price shock—like a sword threatening to cut the inflation anchor loose https://t.co/cLwxvkT6me— Nick Timiraos (@NickTimiraos) March 14, 2022
This chart leaps out 👇
Inflation was supposed to slow as spending shifted from goods to services. Instead, inflationary pressures in services are broadening. Food, energy and fuel prices are jumping too.
Combining these factors increases the chances that inflation will hang around way above the 2% target for a while yet. Headline CPI hit 7.9% last month.
Even stripping out the supply constrained goods, core inflation (excludes food and energy) is expected to stay above target until at least mid-2023.
WSJ
Looking at all of that...
Why WOULDN'T the Fed hike 50 itty bitty bips?!
Because the system's a fragile little flower that won't be able to handle it. For now anyway.
It wasn't so long ago that oil was in full memestock mode. Brent futures hit a high of $137 per barrel... Just over a week later, oil is trading below $100 again.
Oil supplies didn't suddenly increase. Chinese lockdowns weren't in the headlines last week. The Ukraine conflict's still going on.
Soooo, what happened?
Brokers and clearing houses rang their clients...
There's an assumption that commodity traders must be killing it when prices increase.
They MUST be making loadsa money, just look at those prices!
In a stable and steady trend, that might be right.
Most of the time, increased volatility leads to the opposite outcome. High volatility leads to lower liquidity and difficulty in closing positions.
Once those margin requirements increase, it's hard to keep a commodity rally going... Higher margin requirements tie up cash and force the closure of trades, often at unfavourable prices.
Even for the big boys 👇
The trader held talks with Blackstone Inc. for an investment of around $2 billion to $3 billion in preference shares or a similar hybrid instrument, but those talks ended without a deal, said the people, who asked not to be identified as the discussions were private.
Trafigura has also approached Apollo Global Management Inc., BlackRock Inc. and KKR & Co., the people said.
Trafigura faced margin calls in the billions of dollars last week, the people said, as oil prices surged to $139 a barrel and nickel soared 250% in little more than 24 hours.
Trafigura is still tapping the banking sector for funds. It earlier this month announced a $5.3 billion deal to refinance a revolving credit facility, and last week raised an additional $1.2 billion credit facility, expected to be increased to over $2 billion, to help it navigate “unprecedented market conditions and extreme volatility.”
If that's happening at one of the largest commodity trading firms, then it'll be happening elsewhere too.
What's this got to do with the Fed decision?
It comes down to uncertainty & (dis)trust.
When everything seems stable and predictable, liquidity is plentiful, funding is easy to obtain, trust is high and all is well in the world (and the financial system).
The opposite is more true now.
ZeroHedge jumped on the Trafigura story and put their own stamp on it...
Once you strip out the usual hyperbole and DOOM, there's still something there. Zoltan Pozsar's note is linked here 👇
Given the lack of visibility & unknown exposures to Russian sanctions, the Fed would only be adding to the problems if they decided to shock markets with a 50 bps hike at tonight's meeting.
Which is why they'll probably go for the gradual, boring, predictable path.
Will the dollar sell off?
We've been looking at this with Macrodesiac Premium subscribers since January.
After the first rate hike, the dollar has tended to sell off. 👇
But it's a small sample size. And if the sh*t hits the fan, there's only one currency everyone wants...
Until the Saudis start selling all the oil in Chinese Yuan...
Be thankful there are people who find this exciting enough to run the numbers and break down the numerous issues 👇
Huge story. Fascinating to work through how much trade Saudi Arabia can actually conduct in yuan, before running into China's highly restrictive capital account.
Back-of-envelope *maximalist* estimates here: shift could be substantial at first, but soon enough hit limits. (1/9) https://t.co/gjxqQ9zrkX— Simon Rabinovitch (@S_Rabinovitch) March 15, 2022
TL;DR there's a whole bunch of practical and economic reasons that limit the scope of the PetroYuan idea.
Then there are 'real-world' implications 👇
My Saudi contacts tell me there are lots of princes loosing their minds over this today, 15,000 Royals now get a stipend & most of them are paid in USD so they can galavant around the world, not sure many of them want CNY. Can’t downplay the internal risks posed by this for MBS. https://t.co/AYXb4biWmU— Mathew Casey (@matcasey) March 15, 2022
No idea if that's actually true, but I really want to believe it.
Don't know what financial news stories are important and what is complete bullsh*t? Hop onto our filtered news channel.
It's completely free 👇👇👇
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel and stay up to date with all of our videos as they're posted. We'll keep expanding and adding more formats as we go!
Check out our reviews on TrustPilot 👇👇👇
