• Fink 🧠
  • Posts
  • πŸ”” Predictive PMI’s & Stops To Breakeven

πŸ”” Predictive PMI’s & Stops To Breakeven

First up, check out Macrodesiac partner Syscoin πŸ‘‡

Right, unpopular opinion of the day. I like PMI's. I think they're information-rich, and one of the best leading indicators available.

Idiot's guide to PMI's πŸ‘‡

They're not perfect though! And they frequently get misinterpreted due to excessive focus on the number being better or worse than the last time.

The sub-components are a good way to track themes (e.g. supply chain strains) πŸ‘‡

And this is packed full of good info πŸ‘‡

PMI's are not a magic pill, and they don't have all the answers. No panacea. It's all just information.  

But if we think about the economic/business cycles in conjunction with PMI's, there's a sequence that stands out.

As monetary policy is tightened, the business cycle will subsequently start to slow.

Take this example πŸ‘‡

Now, does it matter if the lag is 8 months or 18 months? Well, it's not my chart and I haven't done the maths, but there are definitely more variables to drill into. The speed and amount of tightening are the obvious ones.

Either way, it makes sense that when central banks tighten, this will eventually will slow economic activity.

How about the profit cycle? πŸ‘‡

 the profit cycle is everything and the PMI cycle is one of the clearest, high frequency indicators we have to measure it. if you know the likely direction and approx location of PMI it allows you to think ahead. most play based on yesterday's data (GDP, etc) pic.twitter.com/N0ej4Bdipaβ€” MrBlonde (@MrBlonde_macro) April 7, 2022 

What underpins the assumption here? If demand is strong, price increases can be passed on. Manufacturers struggle to increase output sufficently, and everyone has pricing power.

The end consumer has to suck it up or miss out. In theory, these conditions are peak profitability.

Until...

Worldwide optimism slipped to a 15-month low, underpinned by deterioration in confidence across both the manufacturing and service sectors.

Panellists widely cited concerns surrounding Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, COVID-19 disruptions and their consequent impact on prices and borrowing costs moving forward

As such, growth concerns that have mounted so far may well be warranted as reflected by the latest PMI readings.

Input costs are still going up, while optimism is going down.

And consumers didn't pay down as much of their debt in February as they typically would (after the Christmas spending binge) πŸ‘‡

The direction of travel is clear. Growth is slowing. It's the long and variable lags we have to look out for.

Earnings season starts properly next week.

Last quarter company executives were shouting about their pricing power. We'll be watching to see if they can keep that up...

 https://t.co/R0EfB2mq2f

Jump on Macrodesiac + Discord forever...

3 going! πŸ”₯β€” David Belle (@davidbelle_) April 8, 2022 

Moved my stops to breakeven, can't lose

David had his take on this yesterday πŸ‘‡

 Thoughts behind moving stop to breakeven.

I have mine (it's completely wrong to do, I don't care what anyone says).@Trader_Danteβ€” David Belle (@davidbelle_) April 7, 2022 

A LOT of traders think that moving stops to breakeven is the best way to protect the downside.

If you cut your losers short, and let your winners run you can't lose.

Or maybe you just lose more slowly...

Let's take a look at USDCAD and use a recent example πŸ‘‡

"CAD is approaching a decent area to monitor for a reversal"

And reverse it did.... πŸ‘‡

When you see a daily candle like that, you've got to think odds favour the long.

Imagine steaming in the next morning ready to buy and this is what you find. The box marks the Asian session. πŸ‘‡

Simple strategy: Buy the retest of local support at 1.2492. Stop 10 pips below the Asia low at 1.2470.Conservative target of the next daily level at 1.2588. Get filled as Europe opens, and then it goes nowhere for a bit...

Then this happens...

Asia low was flushed, closed back above. Should see some upside now...

You're onside on the trade, and it looks like it's breaking out of the local range...

Excellent. Stops to breakeven. Nicely in profit and I can't lose now!

Sh*t. Stopped at breakeven. Even the queen's trolling you. And then the trade runs on to target.

At least you didn't lose money though, right?

Of course, there are rules and processes you can follow that might mean you didn't get stopped out in this scenario.

And while this is true in theory πŸ‘‡

If you cut your losers short, and let your winners run you can't lose

In practise, it's a lot harder than just moving your stops to entry. That might cut your losers short, but it will often cut your winners short too...

The point isn't to say that moving stops to breakeven is never a good idea.

It's that moving stops to breakeven just so you feel better or avoid losing... Well, frankly, that's just dumb. The market doesn't care about your feelings.

Don't know what financial news stories are important and what's complete bullsh*t? Hop onto our filtered news channel.

It's completely free πŸ‘‡πŸ‘‡πŸ‘‡

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel and stay up to date with all of our videos as they're posted. We'll keep expanding and adding more formats as we go!

Check out our reviews on TrustPilot πŸ‘‡πŸ‘‡πŸ‘‡